Philosophy 101
Study questions:
Thoreau, "Civil Disobedience"
<>
1. Thoreau clearly believes
he has an obligation to "refuse allegiance" to his government.
On what grounds? What
is the main step he has taken to refuse allegiance?>
2. How does Thoreau describe
the obligations of citizens regarding injustices committed by their
governments?
What course of action does he
suggest in order to resist this injustice?
What reasons does he offer in
favor of this method? What alternative
courses of action does
he consider, and why does he reject them?
3. Consider the following
claim: When one's government is committing serious injustice, one
is justified in
resisting with open,
non-violent lawbreaking. Do you agree
with this general claim? What reasons
could you offer in
defense of your answer?