Philosophy 230
Study questions:  The case of Mary Northern


1.  What are the relevant circumstances in the case of Ms. Northern?  What is the question that
       must be answered.

2.  What is the decision of the Court of Appeals in this case?  What argument(s) do they
       provide in defense of this decision?

3.  Do you think Ms. Northern was competent to refuse treatment in this case?  What argument
       could you offer in defense of your view?  What objections might there be, and how would
       you respond to them?