Philosophy 103
Essay Topic,  Mill's Utilitarianism
Due Tuesday, Nov. 16th


In his classic (and uncreatively titled) work, Utilitarianism, Mill sets out his version of utilitarianism
as a theory of morality.  Your task in this 3-5 page (typed, double-spaced) essay is to set out and
critically assess Mill's theory.  In developing your analysis, you should be sure to provide the following:

1.  A clear, careful explanation of Mill's conception of the good (his hedonism).  This should include
    a careful discussion of his analysis of the qualitative differences among pleasures.  It should also
    include a discussion of the argument he offers in defense of this view in Chpt. 4.

2.  A clear, careful explanation of his account of morally right action.

Once you have set out Mill's account, focusing on these details, you should develop a critical
assessment of it.  You may do so in a number of ways.  Perhaps you think one of the key claims
in his account is false.  If so, explain why exactly you think we should reject it.  Try to consider
what response a defender might offer to your objection.   If you agree completely with Mill's
view, explain what you take to be the most serious objection to his view; then explain how you think
he should respond to this objection.  Finally, consider what your critical evaluation leads you to
conclude.  In light of your discussion, what may we conclude about utilitarianism as a theory of morality?

Enjoy!

Papers are due Nov. 16th

Note:  Please feel free to ask for my help as you're working on your essay.  I'll be happy to answer
            your questions.  I'll even read an outline or a rough draft and give you some ideas for what
            might improve it.
 
Please review Vaughn's thoughtful discussion of how to write a philosophical essay in Chpts. 3
and 4 of his book.  In particular, your essay should have a thesis, and you should state your
thesis early in the paper.  Your thesis is the main claim that you intend to defend in the paper.

Please review my comments on plagiarism in the syllabus. Minimum penalty for intentionally
plagiarized work is an 'F' in the course. You do not need to consult outside sources in
writing this essay; however, if you do consult outside sources, you must cite all quotes
and paraphrases appropriately and include a bibliography listing all sources used.