Change  Therapy  

 

Change therapy for homosexuals is a controversial issue.  Several recent cases have been reported to Family Fellowship leaders and so this website material has been prepared to unify a series of relevant statements from 

"This is information which we as parents and interested professionals feel every Latter-day Saint family dealing with this issue should have."
some members of Family Fellowship and others.  We have concluded that a responsible position on our part is to provide wider access to what we consider the most reliable scientific information on change therapy at our web site. This is information which we as parents and interested professionals feel every Latter-day Saint family dealing with this issue should have.

We hope to provide responsible personal experiences by homosexuals, family members, and therapists who have dealt with issues of reparative or reorientation therapy. An example of the kind of personal experience that has come to our attention is the case of a young returned missionary who has reported his experience in undergoing extensive and expensive reparative therapy which deprived him of his savings for going to college. We have met this man and found him to be sincere and credible. The therapy he describes, which was extreme in its techniques, occurred in 1995 as the result of a referral from Evergreen, a group of professed ex-gay Mormons who affiliate with the Christian Right on this issue. His therapist was so disturbed by the destructive aspects of this man's therapy that he has reported the case to the American Psychological Association. This young man, who has served as Elders Quorum President in his ward in the recent past, feels certain that the kind of therapy he received is still being practiced on Latter-day Saint homosexuals. Jayce's therapy as reported in a newspaper account  is included here as well as an interview on his experience  to illustrate the tragic nature of such misguided therapy.  Another recent case, Mike Summer's therapy, is also included. These two cases are not typical of the usual therapy which Evergreen members participate in, but these reports are disturbing, nonetheless, and seem to tie in some way to Evergreen.

Members within Family Fellowship are frequently approached by those seeking information about reparative therapy. Often, those who come with questions are deeply conflicted between their own experience and the encouragement they receive from others, including from Church leaders, to change their sexual orientation. Not infrequently, such conflict leads to self-destructive behavior including suicide.  Stuart Matis, was such a young man and our discussions with him are reported herein.

Currently there is much confusion and misinformation regarding reparative and reorientation therapy. On the one side, the American Psychiatric Association and the vast majority of practicing psychotherapists (including many Latter-day Saint therapists) believe that such therapy is often inappropriate and sometimes unethical. As of 1999 the APA cites an absence of scientific support for such therapy but there is evidence that it can be damaging. On the other side are a group of organizations and therapists who advocate change and suggest there is evidence to support their position. Among such groups is Evergreen, an organization within the Mormon community, and among such therapists are some Latter-day Saints. Although there is much controversy regarding the issue of change, those within Family Fellowship who have added relevant statements to this material take the position, based
"Most therapists recognize that not all homosexuals have the same degree of homosexual attraction."
on careful and comprehensive evaluation of the arguments and evidence presented on both sides and based on the experience of a large number of Latter-day Saint homosexuals and their families, that, at least for the majority of homosexuals, significant change is not possible. Bisexuals, especially married ones, may be helped, but even there they will generally continue to experience same sex attractions.  We feel in principle that this position is not at variance with that of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which has moved from a position of strongly advocating change to admitting that change may not be possible for all homosexuals. The most recent authoritative statement (Elder Oaks, Ensign, 1995) on this issue does not specifically recommend change therapy. We deplore the way these other non-authoritative sources are tormenting our young Mormons. We think there is much to suggest that change or reparative therapy is destructive, especially for those who are not married.  When we learned of the two recent cases cited above, we determined that these cases should be reported to church leaders, who, like us, were shocked to learn that such therapy is still being promoted in a way that implies church support.

Using the collective wisdom of professional therapists, parents, and priesthood leaders who have had experience counseling with homosexuals, we have decided to be more public in our position on change therapy and more proactive in providing information, assistance and support to those homosexual Latter-day Saints and their families who are dealing with this issue.  At the outset, we think it would be helpful to clarify that "change" is a vague word.  In some of their advertising, Evergreen says they can offer support to those going through a transition (change) from homosexuality to heterosexuality. We suggest that it is clearly misleading to infer that such total change is possible.  As one prominent Mormon psychiatrist has reported to us, sexual orientation comes from susceptibilites beyond volitional control and it becomes largely immutable sometime between 15-20 years of age.  So if same sex attraction is strongly present, and we are talking about something that is persistent beyond  a limited episode of youthful experimentation, then one can expect the attraction to be permanent beyond that age range.  So when we talk about significant change not being possible, we mean a change from homosexual to heterosexual.  What we have found is that the people who talk about their Evergreen or change therapy experiences often are really talking about a change from addictive behavior to non-addictive behavior.   Some may also use the word "change" when they talk about learning to become faithful in their marriages or gaining self esteem.  It is certainly possible to change some attitudes and behaviors relative to sexual attraction, but these changes should not be confused with change in orientation.  We applaud attitude and behavior changes as long as in the process people understand that adult same sex feelings do not disappear and even if they diminish somewhat the person needs to be helped to accept such feelings, rather than being taught to hate them.

Family Fellowship receives a number of inquiries about change therapy from homosexuals, parents, family members, and priesthood leaders. The following questions, along with our answers, are typical:

John writes: I'm wondering about the controversy over whether gays can change or not. I'm 18...just out of high school...and as a good Mormon guy I'd like to go on a mission and get married in the temple. But I have no interest yet in dating girls and I find other guys very attractive.
 

John, you are right to identify this as a "controversy" since there are competing theories about the possibility of homosexuals changing their orientation. Some contend that change is possible and recommend various therapies to effect change. One of the things that complicates the debate over this issue is that those advocating change tend to place all homosexuals into a single category. We believe that it is much more complex than this, that there is a range of orientations between purely heterosexual and purely homosexual. Most therapists recognize that not all homosexuals have the same degree of homosexual attraction. Most therapists believe that those who might be classified as bisexuals have more choice in emphasizing one side or the other of their sexual duality. The majority of these therapists contend that for a person who has a strong, definite and singular attraction to the same sex, significant change is not possible. Based on our extensive experience in working with homosexuals over the past several decades, we believe that for such homosexuals change to heterosexuality is not possible and that entering into reparative or reorientation therapy can have negative consequences.

We encourage you to become informed on this issue before making a decision as to the course of action best suited for you. We suggest you read a number of items we have linked to this document including a fair and balanced web site on so-called reparative, reorientation or conversion therapy which contains material on both sides of the issue as prepared by an organization committed to religious tolerance from Ontario, Canada. Within the Religious Tolerance summary on therapy you can also find the position of the APA and other professional organizations, and a variety of other references and sources you might find helpful. We would also be pleased to put you in touch with a Latter-day Saint therapist familiar with these issues who might be able to help you understand what course of action is best for you.

In the process of this study you no doubt will come across an article which appeared in the Ensign in September of 

"This article was not written by a general authority, and has serious problems from a scientific standpoint."
1999 advocating change therapy.  This article was not written by a general authority, and has serious problems from a scientific standpoint.  Several professionals in Family Fellowship prepared an article critique which describes some of the flaws and, in addition, a knowledgeable BYU Professor has reviewed it for us so we recommend you review these and question the accuracy of the article.

Jennifer, an LDS mom, writes: Our daughter has just told us she is a lesbian. This has been very confusing for us because we love our daughter and yet we are also good members of the Church. When we have sought guidance as to whether our daughter can get help in becoming "straight," we have been given conflicting advice. We are wondering if there is anything that we can do to help her change back into being a normal person.

Jennifer, we understand how challenging it can be for parents to learn that they have a homosexual child. Many of us in Family Fellowship are familiar with the experience you are currently going through. We would be happy to put you in touch with other Latter-day Saint parents who have wrestled with the same problems you are facing. As to your question about changing your daughter "back into being a normal person," it is our belief that your daughter has most likely always had same-sex feelings. She probably recognized these feelings from an early age and found them frightening, or at least confusing. Like most homosexuals, she probably tried to deny that she had these feelings and covered them up.

We don't know all of the reasons why one person is born with opposite-sex and another with same-sex
"Most psychotherapists no longer think of homosexuals as being "abnormal," and most do not believe homosexuals can be "fixed.""
orientations. The causes may be multiple, we simply do not know. Most psychotherapists no longer think of homosexuals as being "abnormal," and most do not believe homosexuals can be "fixed." We recommend that you talk to your daughter about your feelings and try to understand hers. Sometimes it is helpful to have a therapist to help you talk through your feelings. We also encourage you to become more informed about homosexuality in general and about change therapy as summarized in the Religious Tolerance summary.

Since there are a number of Latter-day Saint parents who have had experiences similar to yours, we enclose links which will allow you to read the experiences of parents who have dealt with this issue. We would also be pleased to put you in touch with some who are willing to share their experiences with you if you simply write to us via email at WattsFF@aol.com.

One thing you've probably already noticed is that there are people who strongly align with one side or the other of this issue. Some individual therapists and groups, such as Evergreen, are strongly committed to the proposition that therapy can help gay and lesbian persons "transition" to heterosexuality if they really want to change. These groups tend to focus on certain theories about gay men having poor relationships with their fathers and with males in general. They also propose that lesbians almost universally were sexually abused by men and that this abuse makes these women gravitate toward women as a defensive strategy. Many people, however, consider these groups to be misguided in their efforts to "transition" homosexuals. We think they can help reduce feelings slightly and maybe improve self esteem, but as parents and professionals of the alternate persuasion (no substantial change in orientation possible) we tend to insist that no one in our society initially finds being gay an attractive proposition and that if people could change they would. Whatever you may ultimately decide about this, we think there are a few things you should be made aware of as newcomers to this scene which have become evident to us as we've observed this situation over time.

CONSISTENT REPORTS OF POOR THERAPY OUTCOMES.   First, we have noticed that there seem to be a large number of gay Mormon men (and a few women) who have attempted this therapy over the years and found it was ineffectual.
 


NO SCIENTIFIC SUPPORT FOR THERAPY.    Second, we have not found anyone who can support these procedures on the basis of scientifically plausible information, nor can they show proven therapy outcomes that go beyond minor reductions in the intensity of feelings.

EVERGREEN DOES MUCH HARM AND LITTLE GOOD. PARENT TESTIMONIALS. There are a number of parents who can provide witness to the efforts their children have made in attempting to change their sexual orientation in therapy or through spiritual means. Of the parents listed here who have gay or lesbian children, five of the men have served with distinction as bishops in the LDS church and have in some cases counseled with LDS homosexuals as well as with their own children. As noted, they are aware of no credible evidence that suggests change of orientation is possible. See attached statements by the VanWagoners, the WattsJim BlairMax Berryessa,   Ron Jarvis, Marilyn Frogley,  et al.

BISHOP TESTIMONIALS.   Several bishops who have had extensive experience with gay/lesbian Latter-day Saints have made thoughtful written reports on their observations about spiritual efforts of reorientation. Their accounts emphasize the fact  that sincere individuals often wrestle relentlessly to change their sexual orientation, but ultimately few, if any, seem able to change.   Other bishops report their observations in a discussion organized for presentation on this web site.
 


THERAPISTS AND OTHER PROFESSIONALS DO NOT SUPPORT THERAPY:  We have also been able to consult with other professional therapists or researchers on therapy who have observed the change therapies for decades. One thesis by Elizabeth James at BYU in the 1960s reviewed more than 100 published studies. Most of this work was methodologically flawed and very little long-range outcome data were available. The data that were available tended to show a minority of individuals who were capable of reorientation although the nature of the reorientation was often vaguely described. One researcher, a BYU professor has recently reported to us that he does not believe anyone actually changes but that they often learn to cope better.  Dr. Gary Watts, an MD has discussed change therapy as part of a talk on the misinformation that people have on homosexuality. Our other examinations of therapy efforts and research in this area are perhaps of interest (Footnote A) but do not change the overwhelming impression we have that such therapy is not feasible or practical for young unmarried Mormons, and can only be entertained in the case of married persons and even then management of feelings but not real change of orientation can be expected.
 

 SUMMARY:  The forgoing information helps those of us in Family Fellowship determine our recommendations and goals in this matter.  We are convinced based on all of this evidence that change is not an option for the gay and lesbian young people growing up in the Church.  We recognize that the implications of this are profound.  They are explained in the Religious Tolerance summary on therapy.

"As knowledge of sexual orientation increases, we expect that a consensus will form that adult sexual orientation is unchangeable, and that only bisexuals can decide to change their sexual activity from one gender to the other. Hopefully, the ministries which offer conversion therapy will, in time, drop their attempts to convert people's sexual orientation. They will probably begin to focus on convincing homosexuals that God wishes them to abstain from all sexual activity, and to live a life of loneliness.

This will be a painful transition for conservative Christians. Many of their recent activities to deny equal rights for gays and lesbians have been based upon the belief that homosexuality is a chosen and reversible choice.... As they gradually acknowledge that sexual orientation is not 'catching,' the theoretical justification for many of their discriminatory actions evaporates. "

We feel it is important for those parents who have watched their children try to change, to share that experience with others and with church leaders through this web site.  Such reports can be sent to schorona@isu.edu marked "Change/Change Therapy" to allow posting on this site.  Eventually, church members all over the world will have to recognize that change is not possible, when confronted with the scientific evidence and the growing number of good church families, including general authorities, regional representatives, mission presidents, stake presidents, Relief Society presidents, bishops, temple officiators,  and others who speak to the failed change efforts of their children.  Evergreen and LDS Family Services will have to accept this information if they are ever going to be a safe place for our children to receive help.  They will have to cease their efforts that shame these persons for having sexual feelings, leaving them despondent and discouraged,  and place their focus on helping homosexuals accept unchangeable feelings and instead make efforts to control their behavior.  When that time comes we will all understand that some bisexuals may be able to emphasize their opposite sex attractions and cope in marriage, but that those who are fully homosexual cannot.  For that reason, these organizations will have their major role with bisexuals and those few homosexuals who choose a life of celibacy.  When that time comes we will also be able to have a rational discussion about the choices our children face.  With our children and our church leaders whom we both love and respect we will be able to consider what it is to live an entire life of celibacy without companionship and without the God-given gift of sexual expression, and what other choices there might be.